Scroll To Top

“Three Finger Brown” Had Four Fingers…and a Great Nickname

Jugs

“Three Finger Brown” Had Four Fingers…and a Great Nickname

A look at players’ nicknames from yesterday and today.

Baseball has a long history of players with colorful nicknames. It’s as much a part of the game as the names of teams are. That’s what makes baseball great. Is it a coincidence that perhaps the most famous baseball player of all time, George Herman Ruth, had no fewer than four well-known nicknames? He had many more, but these are the ones that have lasted through the years:

  • The Sultan of Swat
  • The Colossus of Clout
  • The Great Bambino
  • The Babe
  • Even old Yankee Stadium had its own nickname: The House That Ruth Built. Here’s a look at the best nicknames, the most recognized, the old and the new, and a little background here and there. (To make for a quick read, this article leaves off the teams the players were on.)

    Great players. Great nicknames.

    Mordecai Brown, who played for the Cubs from 1903–16, mutilated his hand in a corn shredder when he was seven years old. He had lost only one finger—however, two fingers on the same hand were also mangled. When he got to the majors, he became known as “Three Finger Brown.” It seems political correctness and sensitivity weren’t an issue back then.

    Here are some of the other best-known nicknames in baseball:

    The Say Hey Kid---Willie Mays

    The Iron Horse---Lou Gehrig

    Charlie Hustle---Pete Rose

    Hammerin’ Hank---Hank Aaron

    The Flying Dutchman---Honus Wagner

    The Georgia Peach---Ty Cobb

    Mr. Cub---Ernie Banks

    The Yankee Clipper,Joltin’ Joe---Joe Dimaggio

    The Splendid Splinter, The Kid, Teddy Ballgame---Ted Williams

    The Commerce Comet, The Mic---Mickey Mantle

    “Lefty” isn’t a real name.

    Some player nicknames are so ingrained that we don’t even know what the real name is! No mother would name her kid “Goose,” would she? Then again, “Lefty” Gomez sounds a bit more fun than Vernon Louis Gomez. Here are a few more:

    Whitey Ford---Edward

    Dizzy Dean---Jay

    Daffy Dean---Paul

    Yogi Berra---Lawrence

    Satchel Paige---Leroy

    Pee Wee Reese---Harold

    Bucky Dent---Russell

    Chipper Jones---Larry

    Dusty Baker---Johnnie B.

    Sparky Anderson---George

    Catfish Hunter---Jim

    Goose Gossage---Richard

    Mudcat Grant---James

    Sparky Anderson was also known as “Captain Hook” (a classic nickname!) because he was known to pull a pitcher without hesitation and bring in another.

    A little this, a little that.

    A popular way to create a nickname is to combine parts of the player’s first and last names. Probably one of the first well-known “combo” nicknames was “HoJo,” for the Mets Howard Johnson.

    K-Rod---Francisco Rodriguez

    A-Rod---Alex Rodriguez

    Dice-K---Daisuke Matsuzaka

    A-Gone---Adrian Gonzalez

    Car-Go---Carlos Gonzalez

    Car-Mart---Carlos Martinez

    The real deal.

    The Big Hurt---Frank Thomas

    The Big Unit---Randy Johnson

    The Human Rain Delay---Steve Trachsel

    The Human Vacuum Cleaner---Brooks Robinson

    The Mad Hungarian---Hal Hrabosky

    The Scooter---Phil Rizutto

    The Toy Cannon---Jimmy Wynn Houston

    The Count---John Montefusco

    The Melkman---Melky Cabrera

    Sometimes the player’s nickname practically becomes part of their full name, like this:

    Stan “The Man” Musial

    “Sudden” Sam McDowell

    Enos “Country” Slaughter

    “Cool” Papa Bell

    Dennis “Oil Can” Boyd

    “Shoeless” Joe Jackson

    Walter “Big Train” Johnson

    Will “The Thrill” Clark

    The latest and greatest.

    The old players (and old sportswriters) don’t have anything on today’s bunch. Great nicknames are everywhere!

    Big Papi---David Ortiz

    Joey Bats---Jose Bautista

    The Machine---Albert Pujols

    Flash Gordon---Dee Gordon

    The Toddfather---Todd Frazier

    El Oso Blanco---Evan Gattis

    The Cuban Missile---Aroldis Chapman

    Boomstick---Nelson Cruz

    The Flyin’ Hawaiian---Shane Victorino

    Captain America---David Wright

    Country Breakfast---Billy Butler

    Harangatang---Aaron Harang

    Puddin’ Head---Willie Jones

    Nat Geo---Geo Gonzalez

    The Freak---Tim Lincecum

    La Potencia---Yoenis Cespedes

    Big Pasta---Alfredo Simon

    Thor (Wicked Hammer)---Noah Syndergaard

    The best of the rest.

    Over the past several decades, we’ve had some great ballplayers and some great nicknames for them. You’ll probably recognize most of these, and a few might come to mind that aren’t here…

    Godzilla---Hideki Matsui

    Spaceman---Bill Lee

    Louisiana Lightning---Ken Guidry

    El Duque---Orlando Hernandez

    Cobra---Dave Parker

    Big Cat---Andres Galarraga

    Pops---Willie Stargel

    Penguin---Ron Cey

    Tom Terrific---Tom Seaver

    Le Grande Orange---Rusty Staub

    The Sandman---Mariano Rivera

    Crime Dawg---Fred McGriff

    Doctor K---Dwight Gooden

    The Wizard of Oz---Ozzie Smith

    Dr. Strangeglove---Dick Stuart

    Wild Thing---Mitch Williams

    The Bird---Mark Fiddrich

    Rocket---Roger Clemens

    Big Mac---Mark McGuire

    Yaz---Carl Yazstremski

    Stretch---Willie McCovey

    Donnie Baseball---Don Mattingly

    Mr. November---Derek Jeter

    Mr. October---Reggie Jackson

    Big Puma---Lance Berkman